Purpose and scope
Metaversalize (META), published by Research Expansion Alliance (REA Press), is committed to protecting the integrity, reliability, and fairness of the scholarly record. This statement explains the ethical standards and editorial responsibilities that apply to authors, editors, reviewers, guest editors, and the publisher.
META evaluates submissions on their scholarly merit, relevance to the journal, originality, methodological soundness, transparency, and integrity. The journal draws on relevant international publication-ethics principles and guidance, including the resources of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), while applying policies that are appropriate to its own scope and publishing model.
Editorial independence and fair treatment
Editorial decisions are made independently of commercial, institutional, political, or personal interests. Editors assess manuscripts according to their content and the journal’s scope, without discrimination based on an author’s identity, nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, race, religion, disability, political view, or other personal characteristic. Editors must recuse themselves when a real or potential conflict could affect—or reasonably appear to affect—their judgment.
The Editors-in-Chief have final responsibility for editorial decisions. The publisher provides administrative and technical support while respecting editorial independence and does not influence decisions in exchange for payment, services, or other benefits.
Submissions authored or coauthored by an editor, board member, or publisher employee are subject to the same standards and required external reviews as other submissions. An independent, unconflicted editor handles the manuscript; the author-editor has no role in selecting reviewers, evaluating reports, or deciding the outcome. If both Editors-in-Chief are conflicted, an appropriately qualified, independent senior editor is assigned. Any resulting publication identifies the independent handling and the conflicted editor’s non-involvement.
Authors and contributorship
- All listed authors must have made a substantive contribution to the conception, design, execution, analysis, interpretation, or scholarly presentation of the work, must approve the submitted version, and must accept responsibility for the integrity of their contributions.
- Guest, gift, honorary, and ghost authorship are not acceptable. The corresponding author must ensure that all eligible contributors are included, that the author order is approved by all authors, and that no individual is listed without consent.
- A manuscript must be original, and it must not be under consideration by another journal while it is being evaluated by META. Any related publication, preprint, conference paper, dataset, or earlier version must be disclosed clearly at submission.
- A substantially developed conference paper may be considered only when its prior status is disclosed and the submitted article makes a clear, meaningful contribution beyond the earlier version.
- Requests to add, remove, or reorder authors after submission must include a written explanation and the documented agreement of all authors. META does not adjudicate private authorship disputes; it may pause consideration until the relevant parties or institutions provide appropriate clarification.
Originality, plagiarism, and redundant publication
META uses iThenticate for textual similarity screening as part of its originality checks. Editors interpret matched passages and sources in context. A similarity score alone does not establish plagiarism or determine acceptance or rejection. The Plagiarism Policy explains the screening and response procedures.
Authors must present their work accurately and acknowledge the ideas, words, data, code, images, and other contributions of others. Plagiarism, unattributed appropriation, substantial text recycling, fabrication of citations, and duplicate or redundant publication are unacceptable. Similarity-detection tools may be used as one part of editorial assessment, but a similarity score is not, by itself, a determination of misconduct.
Where a concern arises before or after publication, the journal will assess the available evidence fairly and may request an explanation, supporting files, or information from the relevant institution. Editorial action will be proportionate to the evidence and may include rejection, correction, an expression of concern, or retraction.
Citation integrity
References should be chosen for their relevance and contribution to the argument. Editors and reviewers may recommend missing literature with a clear scholarly reason, but must not seek citations to promote themselves, META, the publisher, or another journal. Acceptance must never depend on adding irrelevant references or entering reciprocal citation arrangements. Authors may explain a reasoned disagreement with a suggested reference; concerns about coercive citation requests may be raised through the journal’s complaints procedure.
Research methods, data, and reproducibility
Authors are responsible for the accuracy and integrity of their methods, data, analyses, figures, code, and conclusions. Fabrication, falsification, deceptive image manipulation, selective reporting, and deliberate omission of material information are prohibited. Methods and assumptions should be described in enough detail to allow informed evaluation and, where feasible, reproduction or independent verification.
Authors should preserve the underlying data and supporting materials for a reasonable period and make data, code, instruments, or other materials available when ethically, legally, and practically possible. If materials cannot be shared, the article should state the relevant access restrictions and explain how qualified researchers may seek access where appropriate.
Ethical oversight, privacy, and consent
Research involving human participants, identifiable personal data, vulnerable groups, or animals must comply with applicable ethical standards and institutional or regulatory requirements. Manuscripts should identify the relevant approval, registration, consent, or exemption, as applicable. Authors must obtain consent for publication when individuals could be identified and must protect confidential or sensitive information.
Editors may request evidence of ethical approval, consent, permissions, or data-protection safeguards. The absence of a formal committee in a particular setting does not remove the author’s responsibility to explain how participants, personal data, or animals were protected.
Conflicts of interest, funding, and editorial services
Authors, editors, reviewers, and guest editors must disclose actual, potential, or reasonably perceived conflicts of interest. Relevant financial support, institutional relationships, personal relationships, professional competition, and other circumstances that could influence the work or its evaluation should be stated openly. Editors and reviewers must decline involvement when impartiality cannot be maintained.
REA Press may provide language-editing or related author support as a service separate from peer review. Such services have no bearing on editorial evaluation, peer-review outcomes, or publication decisions. The journal does not charge submission, peer-review, article-processing, page, colour, supplementary-file, expedited-publication, or mandatory subscription fees; the applicable financial policy provides further details.
Peer review and confidentiality
META uses double-anonymous peer review. Original research articles, methodological contributions, and review or survey articles undergo double-anonymous peer review and may be accepted only after substantive reports from at least two independent external reviewers with relevant expertise. Additional reviews may be sought when needed. A manuscript may be declined at the initial editorial assessment without external review; this does not permit acceptance of these article types without the required reviews. Reviewers advise the editors; the final decision remains an editorial responsibility. Reviewers must assess manuscripts objectively, disclose conflicts, protect confidentiality, and avoid using unpublished material for personal advantage.
Authors, reviewers, and editors must not attempt to compromise reviewer anonymity, manipulate peer review, contact one another about a manuscript outside the journal’s process, or share confidential submission material without permission. Detailed procedures are set out in the Peer Review Policies and Guide for Reviewers.
Generative AI and AI-assisted technologies
Generative artificial intelligence and other AI-assisted technologies may be used only responsibly and under meaningful human oversight. AI systems cannot be listed as authors or take responsibility for a manuscript. Authors must disclose substantive use of AI in drafting, rewriting, translation, organization, reference work, coding, analysis, interpretation, or figure creation, and must verify all resulting claims, sources, citations, code, images, and outputs.
AI-generated material must not be used to fabricate or manipulate data, results, images, references, or identities. Authors must protect other people’s confidential or unpublished work, personal data, and restricted third-party content. Content may be shared with an external AI service only when authorized and consistent with confidentiality, rights, institutional, and funder obligations. Authors must check the service’s privacy and data-retention terms before sharing their own work. Editors must protect confidentiality and must not upload manuscript or review content to AI tools.
Reviewers must not upload, paste, or otherwise enter confidential manuscript or peer review material into AI tools. This includes unpublished manuscripts and extracts, figures, data, review reports and drafts, and editorial correspondence. The journal may expressly permit AI assistance only for limited language or structural editing of non-confidential text. Reviewers must disclose any such use to the editor, verify the output, and take full responsibility for the report. AI must not substitute for the reviewer’s independent scholarly judgment or generate a recommendation or decision.
The Guide for Authors and Guide for Reviewers provide the operational requirements.
Allegations of misconduct and editorial response
META takes concerns about research or publication misconduct seriously, whether they are raised before or after publication. Concerns may include plagiarism, fabrication or falsification, unethical research, undisclosed conflicts, authorship manipulation, duplicate publication, copyright infringement, peer-review manipulation, or misuse of confidential material.
The journal will conduct an initial editorial assessment, give the relevant parties a fair opportunity to respond where appropriate, and seek further evidence or institutional clarification when necessary. The process is intended to protect the integrity of the record and the rights of all parties; it does not presume misconduct solely from an allegation.
Corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions
When a published article contains a limited, honest error that does not invalidate its main findings, META may publish a clearly linked correction. When the reliability of an article cannot yet be established, the journal may publish an expression of concern while further information is sought.
Retraction may be considered when findings are demonstrably unreliable because of major error, fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, redundant publication, unauthorised use of material, unethical research, a seriously undisclosed competing interest, or a compromised peer-review process. Retraction is a mechanism for correcting the scholarly record, not a punishment. A retraction notice will be clearly identified, linked to the original article, freely available, and sufficiently specific about the reason and the party issuing the notice. The original record will not be altered or removed except in exceptional circumstances where legal, privacy, or serious public-safety considerations require it.
An authorship dispute alone will not normally justify retraction when the findings and data remain reliable; a documented correction to the author or contributor record may instead be considered.
Complaints, appeals, and post-publication discussion
Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they can identify a substantial procedural error, a material misunderstanding of the manuscript, or relevant evidence that was not considered. An appeal is not a substitute for disagreement with the scholarly judgment of the editors or reviewers. Complaints about editorial conduct, publication ethics, or the publisher should be submitted through the journal’s Complaint page or Contact Us page.
Complaints and appeals will be handled as impartially and confidentially as the circumstances allow. If a complaint concerns an editor or an individual involved in the original decision, it will be assigned to an uninvolved person with appropriate authority. META welcomes substantiated post-publication comments and will assess credible concerns in accordance with this statement.
Related policies
This statement should be read together with the About the Journal page, Guide for Authors, Peer Review Policies, Open Access Policy, and Financial Policies. META also draws on relevant COPE resources, including the COPE Core Practices and COPE Retraction Guidelines, as applicable to the circumstances.