Complaints and Appeals

Metaversalize (META) welcomes well-founded concerns about its editorial work and published content. A complaint asks the journal to examine conduct, procedure, or integrity; an appeal asks it to reconsider an editorial decision on specific grounds. Both receive fair consideration, with handling independent of the person or decision being challenged.

Where to write and what to include

For journal matters, email meta@reapress.com with the subject META Complaint or META Appeal. Include:

  • the manuscript ID, article title, DOI, or relevant page link;
  • a concise account of the concern and, for an appeal, the decision and its date;
  • the specific grounds, relevant correspondence, and supporting evidence; and
  • the outcome or clarification sought and a contact address for a reply.

Submit only material needed to assess the matter and identify any confidentiality concerns. A concern need not be proved in full before it is reported; explain what is known and what remains uncertain. Anonymous concerns are assessed on their substance and available evidence, although lack of contact details may limit clarification or feedback.

Complaints about conduct, procedure, or integrity

Authors, reviewers, readers, institutions, and other concerned parties may raise issues involving editorial handling, peer review, conflicts of interest, authorship, originality, research reporting, or the publication record. The journal examines the relevant records, seeks responses from those concerned where appropriate, and may request institutional clarification or specialist advice. An allegation alone does not establish misconduct. META does not adjudicate private authorship disputes; it may seek an institutional determination before acting on a disputed authorship record.

Where published work requires action, the response follows the Publication Ethics Statement and the policy on corrections and the publication record. Possible responses include clarification, correction, an expression of concern, or retraction, according to the evidence. Material changes to the scholarly record are documented transparently.

Appeals against editorial decisions

The corresponding author should submit a reasoned appeal on behalf of the authors, addressing the decision and the relevant points in the assessment. Grounds may include a substantial procedural error, a material misunderstanding of the manuscript, an unmanaged conflict of interest, or relevant evidence that was not considered. Disagreement with a scholarly judgment, without a specific basis for reconsideration, is insufficient.

An uninvolved, appropriately qualified and unconflicted editor or assessor reviews the grounds and relevant records. The original handling editor may provide information but does not decide the appeal against their own decision. Additional independent assessment may be sought where needed. The written outcome explains whether the decision is upheld, further editorial assessment or peer review is required, or another justified action will be taken. An appeal does not guarantee reconsideration through external review or acceptance. Further review of the appeal outcome requires substantive new evidence or a specific unresolved procedural concern; repeated disagreement alone does not reopen a concluded matter.

Independent handling and escalation

The editorial office routes each case to a person with appropriate authority who was not involved in the matter and has no relevant conflict. A complaint concerning one Editor-in-Chief is referred to the other, provided they are uninvolved and unconflicted. If both Editors-in-Chief are involved or conflicted, an unconflicted Deputy Editor or another appropriately qualified independent assessor is assigned. The person complained about must not investigate or decide the complaint against themselves.

For publisher services, technical access, privacy, or publisher-level administration, contact info@reapress.com. This address may also be used to request independent routing if the normal journal channel is implicated or has not responded after a follow-up. REA Press arranges appropriate administrative oversight without substituting a commercial or ownership decision for independent scholarly judgment.

Response times, confidentiality, and outcome

META aims to acknowledge receipt within three working days and provide a substantive response within two weeks. These are service targets, not guaranteed resolution deadlines. If investigation takes longer, the journal explains the delay and gives an update or an expected date for further contact. Acknowledgment confirms receipt, not agreement with the allegation or appeal.

Information is shared only as necessary for fair assessment, a response from those concerned, institutional investigation, or applicable legal obligations. Absolute confidentiality cannot be promised; reviewer identities and confidential review material remain protected under the Peer Review Policies, with any necessary disclosure limited to its justified purpose. Relevant correspondence, evidence, handling decisions, and outcomes are documented.

The journal communicates its conclusion and reasons as far as confidentiality and the rights of others permit. Raising a concern or appeal does not, in itself, prejudice the treatment of a manuscript or future submission. Every editorial decision remains based on scholarly merit and integrity.

Last reviewed: 9 November 2026.