Metaversalize (META) welcomes questions from authors, reviewers, readers, and research institutions. This page summarizes the journal’s general practice; where a linked policy applies, that policy governs.

What does META publish?

META publishes original research articles, methodological and computational contributions, and focused review or survey articles concerning the representation, analysis, quantification, and responsible use of uncertainty. A manuscript should engage uncertainty as a substantive scientific issue—such as incompleteness, ambiguity, variability, conflict, missingness, distribution shift, or limited knowledge—and should make a clear contribution within the journal’s scope.

See the journal’s Aims and Scope and Guide for Authors.

Does META accept review articles?

Yes. META considers focused, critical, systematic, and state-of-the-art reviews when they organize and interpret the evidence rather than merely list publications. A strong review states a meaningful question, explains its search or selection method where applicable, synthesizes the literature critically, acknowledges limitations, and identifies defensible directions for future work. Systematic reviews should report their sources, search period, eligibility criteria, selection process, synthesis method, and limitations; PRISMA or another appropriate reporting framework should be used where applicable.

Does META charge authors or readers?

No. META currently charges no submission fee, peer-review fee, article processing charge, page or colour charge, supplementary-material fee, or expedited-publication fee. Readers do not need a paid subscription to access the journal’s published content. The journal is supported by REA Press.

REA may offer optional language-editing assistance. It is entirely separate from editorial assessment and peer review; using or declining it has no influence on an editorial decision, and acceptance is never conditional on purchasing or obtaining language editing. See the Financial Policies.

What license applies to published articles?

META publishes open access under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license. Authors retain copyright and grant REA Press a non-exclusive, worldwide license to publish, reproduce, distribute, display, and make the article available through the journal’s platform and scholarly dissemination channels. Authors remain responsible for obtaining permission for third-party material that is not covered by the article’s license.

How do I submit a manuscript?

Submit through the journal’s online system. Before submitting, confirm that the work is original, fits META’s scope, is not under consideration elsewhere and has been approved by all listed authors. Upload an anonymized manuscript, the completed Title Page and Declarations form, and a separate signed Conflict of Interest Declaration from each author. Upload both kinds of completed forms for the editorial office only. Each corresponding author must provide an active email address and an ORCID iD. ORCID is recommended for all other authors. Download the current files from the submission guide.

The complete requirements are set out in the Guide for Authors.

What are the abstract, keyword, and reference limits?

Provide an English abstract of 150–280 words and 3–7 keywords or key phrases. The usual reference limits are 40 for original research and methodological contributions and 100 for narrative or critical reviews and literature surveys. Explain any scientifically justified exception in the cover letter. For systematic reviews, scoping reviews and meta-analyses, 100 is an editorial review threshold. Retain all eligible studies and essential evidence. See the Guide for Authors.

Does META use similarity screening?

Yes. META uses iThenticate to screen manuscripts for textual similarity. Editors review the matched sources and context; a similarity percentage is not, by itself, a finding of plagiarism or an automatic acceptance or rejection threshold. See the Plagiarism Policy.

What peer-review model does META use?

Original research articles, methodological contributions, and review or survey articles undergo double-anonymous peer review and may be accepted only after substantive reports from at least two independent external reviewers with relevant expertise. A submission may be returned for completion or declined during initial editorial assessment; these outcomes do not constitute acceptance without peer review. The editor may seek additional expertise when needed. Reviewer recommendations inform the editor, who remains responsible for the decision on scholarly merit, relevance, research integrity, and the evidence presented.

See the journal’s Peer Review Policies and Guide for Reviewers.

How long does the editorial and peer-review process take?

META does not promise a fixed decision or publication time. Initial assessment, reviewer recruitment, review, revision, and editorial deliberation depend on the manuscript’s subject, complexity, completeness, and reviewer availability. Authors can follow the status in the submission system and may contact the editorial office if a submission has remained without a meaningful update for an unusually long period. A request for an update does not itself affect the editorial decision.

Why might a manuscript be declined before external review?

A manuscript may be declined at the editorial stage when it is outside the journal’s scope, does not offer a sufficiently substantive contribution, is materially incomplete, does not support its claims with an appropriate method or evidence, cannot be evaluated fairly in its submitted form, or raises unresolved ethical, authorship, originality, or research-integrity concerns. A manuscript may also be returned for correction when essential metadata, declarations, anonymization, files, or permissions are missing. Editorial screening is not a judgment about the author’s wider research record.

What improves a manuscript’s publication prospects?

There is no formula that guarantees acceptance. Authors should focus on a clear research question, a meaningful contribution to uncertainty research, explicit assumptions, appropriate baselines or comparisons, transparent methods, reproducible analysis where feasible, accurate and balanced references, a candid account of limitations, and conclusions that are calibrated to the evidence. A manuscript should follow the journal’s scope and reporting requirements rather than attempt to optimize for a presumed editorial preference.

May I submit a preprint, conference paper, or related earlier version?

Authors must disclose any preprint, conference paper, technical report, dissertation chapter, or other related version when submitting. The editor will assess the degree of overlap, the originality of the submitted contribution, and any relevant copyright or permission issue. A manuscript must not be under simultaneous consideration by another journal. Authors should explain clearly what is new and provide links or copies of related versions when requested.

Can the authorship or author order be changed after submission?

Requests to add, remove, or reorder authors must be submitted in writing by the corresponding author, with a clear explanation and the written agreement of all authors, including anyone being added or removed. META may request institutional clarification where appropriate. The journal will not treat authorship changes as a routine administrative edit, and review or publication-related action may be paused until the matter is resolved. After publication, a justified change to the author or contributor record is handled transparently through an appropriate correction; META does not adjudicate private authorship disputes.

What is META’s policy on generative AI and AI-assisted tools?

Responsible use of generative AI or other AI-assisted tools is permitted under meaningful human oversight. AI tools cannot be listed as authors, and human authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, confidentiality, and final wording of the work.

  • Material AI assistance with drafting, rewriting, translation, references, code, analysis, interpretation, or figures must be disclosed.
  • The disclosure should identify the tool or service, its version or date where available, its purpose, and the extent of human review and control.
  • AI used in research design, data collection, analysis, model development, coding, or interpretation should also be described in the Methods section with relevant validation and reproducibility information.
  • Authors must verify AI-generated claims, sources, citations, code, and outputs. Fabricated or manipulated data, results, images, or references are unacceptable.
  • Authors must protect peer-review material, other people’s confidential or unpublished work, personal data, and restricted third-party content. Content may be shared with an external AI service only with the necessary authorization and in accordance with confidentiality, intellectual-property, institutional, and funder obligations. Authors should check the service’s privacy and data-retention terms before sharing their own work.

See the full Guide for Authors for the required disclosure format.

What should authors report about data, code, and research ethics?

Where relevant, authors should provide a data-availability and code-availability statement, describe meaningful restrictions, and provide enough methodological detail for the work to be assessed and reproduced. Research involving human participants, animals, personal data, or identifiable material should include the applicable ethics oversight, consent, privacy, and permission information. When data or code cannot be shared, authors should explain why and describe what can be made available for verification.

When is a DOI assigned?

When a DOI is assigned through mEDRA, it is displayed with the article’s publication record and may also appear in the published files. Authors should never invent, guess, or insert an unassigned DOI. The published article record is the journal’s version of record.

How are accepted manuscripts prepared and published?

After acceptance, a manuscript may undergo editorial preparation, copyediting, typesetting, and author proof review. Authors are expected to check proofs promptly and to limit proof corrections to errors or essential clarifications. Publication timing depends on complete files and metadata, production requirements, and proof approval; META does not guarantee a fixed number of days between acceptance and online publication.

Can a published article be corrected or retracted?

Yes. META maintains the integrity of the published record. If a published article contains a material error or raises a credible research-integrity concern, the journal may publish a correction, editor’s note, expression of concern, or retraction, as appropriate to the evidence and circumstances. The notice and its reason will be linked transparently to the article record. See the Publication Ethics Statement and Crossmark Policy.

How can I appeal an editorial decision?

An appeal should identify a substantial procedural error, a material misunderstanding of the manuscript, or relevant evidence that was not considered. An appeal is not a mechanism for reopening a decision solely because an author disagrees with the editors’ or reviewers’ scholarly judgment. Appeals are considered separately from ordinary correspondence and may result in confirmation of the decision, further assessment, or another appropriate editorial action. See the Peer Review Policies and Complaint procedure.

How do I raise a complaint or a publication-ethics concern?

For a complaint about META’s editorial process, peer review, publication ethics, authorship, conflicts of interest, published content, or related journal operations, email meta@reapress.com with the subject line META Complaint. Please include the relevant manuscript or article identifier, a concise description of the concern, and supporting evidence where available. Matters concerning REA Press as publisher—including publisher-level administrative, financial, privacy, or legal issues—may be directed to info@reapress.com. See the full Complaint procedure.

May authors share their published article?

Yes. Subject to the CC BY 4.0 license and any third-party rights, authors may share the final published article through an institutional or subject repository and other lawful scholarly channels.

For long-term digital preservation, META participates in the PKP Preservation Network (PKP PN). See the journal’s preservation statement for confirmed issue coverage.

Who should I contact if my question is not answered here?

For questions about a submission, manuscript status, peer review, editorial policy, or a published article, please contact the journal at meta@reapress.com or use the Contact Us page. For general publisher-level matters, use info@reapress.com.